Site icon Ahotor 92.3 FM

Assess all 261 MMDCEs scientifically and transparently – Governance expert urges Mahama

Local governance expert, Isaac Amon–Kotei, has called on President John Dramani Mahama to ensure that the performance assessment of all 261 Metropolitan, Municipal and District Chief Executives (MMDCEs) is conducted through a scientific, transparent and evidence-based process.

He said the exercise must go beyond political complaints, petitions and allegations, arguing that government needs a credible assessment framework to establish which MMDCEs are delivering on their mandates and those falling short of expectations.

Speaking on Ahotor 92.3 FM’s morning show, Adekyee Mu Nsem, hosted by Nana Dogbe, Mr Amon-Kotei proposed the use of established local governance assessment tools, including the Urban Governance Index (UGI), Local Governance Barometer (LGB) and Citizens’ Report Card, also known as the Citizens’ Scorecard.

According to him, these tools provide measurable indicators for evaluating the effectiveness of local government administration, fairness in the distribution of development projects, public participation and accountability.

He explained that the Urban Governance Index could help assess the performance of assemblies in service delivery, equitable distribution of resources, citizen engagement and accountability, while the Local Governance Barometer provides qualitative and quantitative indicators for measuring local government performance.

On the Citizens’ Report Card, Mr Amon-Kotei proposed that MMDCEs first undertake self-assessments through structured questionnaires, with their responses subsequently subjected to independent verification.

He said a verification team should examine claims made by the MMDCEs regarding projects executed, funds utilised and other development interventions before engaging residents, civil society organisations and other stakeholders to obtain independent assessments of their performance.

He maintained that such an approach would provide the President with reliable information and key performance indicators (KPIs) to guide decisions on the MMDCEs rather than relying solely on political allegations and petitions.

Assess assemblies on funding and development outcomes

Mr Amon-Kotei also called for the assessment to examine how assemblies utilise financial resources allocated to them, stressing that their performance must be measured against the funds available to them and the development outcomes they achieve.

He cited the District Assemblies Common Fund (DACF), explaining that the allocation to assemblies had historically been pegged at five per cent of national revenue before subsequent adjustments.

He also raised concerns about the allocation of portions of the fund to special projects, insisting that the distribution and utilisation of such resources must be properly scrutinised.

According to him, efforts have been made under the current funding arrangement to ensure that each assembly receives a minimum allocation of about GH¢15 million.

However, he noted significant differences in the revenue-generating capacities of assemblies, with some reportedly generating between GH¢12 million and GH¢15 million annually through Internally Generated Funds (IGF), while others struggle to raise even GH¢800,000.

He questioned why some assemblies continue to struggle with development delivery despite having financial resources available to them, arguing that the assessment must establish whether allocated funds are being translated into tangible projects.

He stressed that MMDCEs must account for public resources entrusted to their assemblies and demonstrate the development outcomes achieved with those funds.

MMDCEs must deliver projects within agreed timelines

The governance expert further urged assemblies to work within clearly defined timelines and ensure that development commitments are fulfilled.

He identified markets, educational infrastructure, including kindergarten facilities, sanitation improvements and other community-based projects as areas that should feature prominently in the assessment.

He argued that where funds have been made available but projects are not completed within agreed timelines, the performance of the responsible local authorities must be questioned.

He also emphasised the need for assemblies to ensure that resources allocated to persons with disabilities reach the intended beneficiaries.

He said persons with disabilities must be involved in determining how such resources are utilised to ensure that interventions respond to their actual needs.

Calls for stronger citizen participation

On citizen participation, Mr Amon-Kotei said MMDCEs must regularly engage traditional authorities, community leaders and residents to identify development priorities.

He proposed that assemblies organise town hall meetings, particularly towards the end of each year, to allow residents to outline the projects and interventions they expect in their communities.

He explained that although technical officers may prepare development plans, such plans must reflect the actual needs of residents.

Using solid waste management as an example, he said assemblies must understand the sanitation challenges confronting individual electoral areas and develop practical solutions that residents can adopt.

He noted that some electoral areas have populations of about 15,000, making it necessary for assemblies to understand household waste disposal practices and the challenges residents face.

He said residents must be educated and provided with appropriate waste management systems to prevent refuse from accumulating in communities.

Mr Amon-Kotei also called on assemblies to strengthen their general assembly meetings, noting that they are expected to meet at least three times annually.

MMDCEs must prioritise administration over party politics

Mr Amon-Kotei further argued that local government administration is predominantly technical, estimating that about 80 per cent of the responsibilities of assemblies involve technical and administrative functions, while 20 per cent are political.

He identified supervision, administration, coordination of development activities and chairing executive committee meetings among the core responsibilities of MMDCEs.

He cautioned that excessive involvement in party-political activities could distract MMDCEs from their primary responsibilities of ensuring effective administration and development.

According to him, being appointed by a political administration should not prevent MMDCEs from discharging their professional responsibilities.

He compared the situation to the appointment of a Chief Justice, explaining that although the President makes the appointment, the individual is expected to perform the duties of the office professionally and independently.

He therefore urged MMDCEs to focus on delivering development and improving local administration rather than allowing partisan interests to dominate their work.

Questions separation of MMDCE appointments from the Executive

Addressing calls for the appointment of MMDCEs to be separated from the Executive to reduce political interference, Mr Amon-Kotei questioned whether political appointments necessarily prevent individuals from performing their duties professionally.

He argued that the priority should be to establish clear performance criteria and institutional guidelines that define the responsibilities and expectations of MMDCEs, irrespective of their political affiliations.

He maintained that their performance should be judged by their ability to deliver on their mandates rather than their political connections.

Government must consider funding constraints in assessing MMDCEs

Mr Amon-Kotei also highlighted what he considered a difference in approach between the current administration of President John Dramani Mahama and the previous administration of former President Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo regarding the monitoring of district-level development projects.

He said efforts to document development projects across districts and make the information accessible through a central monitoring dashboard could provide a clearer picture of progress and challenges at the local level.

However, he cautioned against holding MMDCEs solely responsible for development challenges without examining the funding decisions and policy constraints imposed by central government.

He explained that where Cabinet decisions determine the proportion of funds allocated to assemblies or the resources available for development projects, responsibility for the resulting challenges should not rest entirely on local administrators.

He said it would be unfair to expect MMDCEs to deliver projects without adequately considering the financial resources made available to them.

Assessment must guide Mahama’s decisions

Mr Amon-Kotei said a comprehensive assessment of all 261 MMDCEs was necessary because residents largely judge government through the development and improvements they experience in their communities.

He referred to discussions surrounding Global InfoAnalytics findings suggesting that some constituencies could potentially change their political allegiance, arguing that concerns about local development must be taken seriously.

He questioned why residents would continue to support a governing party in communities where they could not identify meaningful development.

He, however, stressed that such concerns must be investigated through credible assessment rather than political speculation.

He maintained that a comprehensive evaluation would help President Mahama distinguish between assemblies performing effectively, those facing financial or administrative challenges, and those failing to deliver despite having the necessary resources.

He concluded that the President’s directive should be implemented through a credible framework combining financial accountability, independent verification, citizen participation and measurable development targets.

According to him, the ultimate objective must be to ensure that assemblies account for public funds and translate government resources into visible improvements in the lives of residents.

Story by Stephen Kwaku Owusu Mintah

Exit mobile version